Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.

4 Bay Ln
4 Bay Ln
4 Bay Ln
4 Bay Ln
SEE ALL PHOTOS
4 Bay Ln
4 Bay Ln
4 Bay Ln
4 Bay Ln
Sold

4 Bay Ln

4 Bay Lane, Water Mill, NY 11976

$12,250,000
What a classic Hamptons home should be: South of the highway on approximately 2.8 acres, a restored, turn-of-the-century, shingle-style residence with pool, tennis, waterfront guest cottage, and 112 ft +/- waterfront on Mecox Bay including dock and evening sunsets. Storybook setting approached from a long hedged drive to its own parking court that leads to the main residence, a converted barn that retains many original details from wide plank wood floors to extensive bead board walls and interior sliding wood doors. Renovated and maintained regularly for many years, the residence and its waterside cottage both feature new kitchens with marble counters, appliances, and fully integrated fiber optics. The attached screened porch looks out over a stone patio with central mature trees, stone walls, and lawn down to the waterside cottage and dock. A brick patio off the dining and kitchen borders the in-ground heated Gunite pool, and the lawn extends to the tennis court and viewing pavilion. The separate garage offers spaces for two vehicles. This complete-estate offers privacy, bucolic landscaping, and water views. Once settled, you'll never want to leave.

6
beds

6
baths

4,400 Sq.Ft. LIVING AREA

Terry Cohen

Terry Cohen

Features & Amenities

Interior

  • total bedrooms6
  • Total bathrooms6
  • full bathrooms6

Area & Lot

  • Status Sold
  • Living Area4,400 Sq.Ft.
  • MLS® ID890494
  • YEAR BUILT1900
  • NeighborhoodMontauk

Financial

  • Sales Price$12,250,000

With over $3 billion in closed sales and 25+ years in Hamptons real estate, Terry Cohen brings strategy, discretion, and expert insight to every transaction. Her deep knowledge of land use, development, and design helps clients unlock both lifestyle and long-term value. From raw land to iconic estates, Terry delivers results that stand the test of time. Always happy to share market analysis and up-to-date information regarding your home — feel free to call anytime for a chat.

Follow Me on Instagram